I want to thank everyone who has taken the time to post and comment on our ongoing discussion about race, genetics and sport. I hope you all felt comfortable adding your opinion. I started to feel like this site became a message board more than a blog, but I think I’m okay with that. I really don’t want to just sit here and spew out posts from my own head. I’d much rather be a part of a larger dialogue that teaches me something new.
I would like to start by echoing the sentiments of Coach Bright.
The first thoughts that come to my head after reading this response is that it would be helpful to question people’s views constructively rather than attempt to belittle them. Asking someone if they truly believe a statement they made is not constructive and discourages others to reply.
It can be difficult to separate emotions from such a potentially loaded conversation, but that makes it even more important to do so. Having a safe and constructive environment to have polarized conversations is critical to moving forward.
That being said, I would like to point out exactly how not to make your point in such a discussion. Another athlete who’s name is imprinted on the wall of my office (sorry, the picture isn’t up yet) brought a website to my attention that is somewhat related to our conversation. The website, Caste Football, makes some very polarizing comments and I’m not 100% sure what type of reaction they are looking for from putting together such a website.
Are they looking to jump-start a controversy and get their opinion any and all possible attention. They seem to work with the mindset that “negative attention is still attention” and “there’s no such thing as bad publicity.” In the ‘About Us’ section of their website the posit
We respect the fact that blacks make good football players. But we believe that by looking at football and sports overall through an objective lens rather than simply accepting the propaganda slant of the media, it is clear and obvious that whites are just as good as if not better athletes than blacks.
To give just one example, even though whites are only 10 percent of the world’s population, they win over 90 percent of the medals at the Winter Olympics and over 70 percent of the medals at the Summer Olympics, including many medals in sprinting and jumping.
Caste Football’s goal is to see that white athletes are respected for their abilities, and that they receive the same opportunities to succeed as non-white athletes.
By making statements of this nature, any semblance of a constructive conversation comes to a screeching halt. Nothing annoys me more than seeing someone twist stats and figures to fit their best interests. In this case, it is obvious that the Olympics are dominated by the industrialized world. That 10% of the world’s population that is caucasian may make up 50% of the industrialized population. (I’m hypothesizing on the 50% just to make a point.)
Regardless, I see this same thing happen time after time again in my job. So many coaches twist and manipulate facts and numbers to make their programs look strong. What do you see when a program has 4 Srs, 3 Jrs, 4 Sos, and 14 Fr. One that is “rebuilding and has a great future” or one that brings in 15 freshmen every year and gives them a 25% chance to survive or not quit before their sophomore year. They both look the same from the outside world. Sorry, that is way off topic, but something that I just wanted to get out there and off my chest. It really aggravates me to see so many HS seniors straight up lied to year in and year out.
Back to what you’re hear to talk about. The same athlete who brought Caste Football to my attention made a good DIII track analogy.
They’ll point to Andrew Rock and say that he didn’t get an athletic scholarship because he was white, and a black athlete with the same credentials would have. They look at Andrew Rock and see 44.35 World Champ silver medalist and not a 40 point 300 hurdler as junior in high school (amazing what you can find with a simple google search) that had no chance of getting a scholarship. Furthermore, people on that site claim that blacks excel in sports because of frequent use of performing enhancing drugs, or that somehow these drugs do more to aid black athletes than white athletes (I wish I was making this up). I feel arguments like this accomplish nothing, because when a white athlete begins to run times on par with those dominating the sports, who can say that that person is not on drugs?
And they can’t. This is exactly the point. It is sometimes okay to make unproved or unsubstantiated comments, but realize that they are so and that they carry less weight. When you make an unsupported statement, but pose it as if you were saying 2+2=4 then you destroy any and all credibility you may have had.
No one has ever posted or tried to post anything on this site like what Caste Football tries to promote; however, I was contacted by a few individuals who had thoughts on the discussion but were hesitant to add to the conversation. Please, don’t be. We are all human and all make mistakes. Fred Jones put it best in his first post with,
No matter what, race is always a tough issue to talk about in a racial diverse setting. We, as leaders, have to create an environment where people can express their real feelings without feeling judged or identified as a racist. It’s important for ideas to be expressed so that we can know what people really think and move towards a better understanding of one another.
In other words, we all need to be comfortable saying something stupid so that we can all grow together. We learn more from our mistakes than we do from our victories. If you’re thinking it, then I can guarantee that there are a bunch of other people wondering the same thing. That being said, it is imperative that if we ever feel insulted or criticized by someone’s comments that we are able to separate our emotions from the topic. We need to let others speak their mind and be patient with them. It’s the only way to learn from each other.